Cluster Cluster on the Wall, Who's the Clearest of Them All?
Abstract
- Abstract
-
en
This long essay reflects on John's role as Cluster Chronicler, the vocabulary used by the Cluster's scholars, and clarity in academic writing. It draws on works by Eric Hayot, Harry G. Frankfurt and others, and includes hymn-style parodies of Cluster concepts. It also reports conversations with Cluster colleagues and describes an artist talk at the virtual conference.
Machine-generated
by Claude Haiku 5.5
Value Annotations
Value Annotations
- Generated by
- Claude Haiku 5.5
Subjects
People & roles
- Author
- John, Elnathan
Origins & context
- Title
- Cluster Cluster on the Wall, Who's the Clearest of Them All?
- Language
- English
- Series
- Cluster Chronicles
- Date
- August 2, 2021
- Related
- Cluster Modalities
Identifiers & sources
- Identifier
- john-2021-essay-clearest
Full text
- Full text
- In ordinary life, when a listener cannot understand what someone has said, this is the usual exchange: Listener: I cannot understand what you are saying Speaker: Let me try to say it more clearly But in scholarly writing In the 20th century, other rules apply. This is the implicit exchange: Reader: I cannot understand what your are saying Academic Writer: Too bad. The problem is that you are an unsophisticated and untrained reader. If you were smarter, you would understand me. — Dancing With Professors, The Trouble With Academic Prose, Patricia Nelson Limerick. It is not immediately clear how I am going to be doing the job of “chronicling” the Cluster over the four weeks I am supposed to be spending in this town famous, among other things, for its Institute of African Studies. However, I am pleased that the kind Spokesperson of the Cluster, who had also previously invited me to give a keynote at the end of the last conference, thought of me to do this. As I try to figure out how to begin, I get an invitation from a scholar of Islamic Studies to speak to his class. He has a contemplative gaze and picks his words so carefully that often I am not sure if he has finished a sentence. He knows a lot about one of the subjects I have been researching for years, so I listen closely. He drives me from the office to his class, a short distance away. On the way we chat about politics and political figures in Nigeria many of whom he met personally while working there. We discuss sharia and northern Nigeria and he asks what I think the state of things are now. When we get to the class, the room is aired and after the introductions, I try to connect with the students by creating points of convergence between my work and their various fields of study. Apart from the page, the classroom is where I feel most comfortable, but there is something not quite right here. Everyone else is attentive apart from two people, one of whom is supposed to be a coordinator of the group. She… Read the full text about 3,724 words
Linked resources
Linked resources 1 connection to this record
No connections match this filter.
Records on similar topics
Records about similar topics, from anywhere in the collection and in any language. The percentage shows how closely each one matches this record.
